*Editor’s Note: This was #1 on our Top Posts of 2012.
_
I was reminded recently by a local TV preacher (asking for money in exchange for prayers, of course) how badly the “prosperity gospel” distorts the gospel of Christ. Here are three major things that I think the prosperity gospel does:
1. Cheapens Grace
The gospel of Jesus Christ is built upon the fact that God’s wrath needed to be satisfied by the shedding of blood in order for sinners to be taken out from under this wrath. Jesus did not have your material wealth in mind when he died on the cross. No, Jesus had your eternal soul in mind. Your wealth on earth is judged by others, but your soul is judged by God. Grace is poured out because you are born in spiritual poverty with no hope, not because your 401k is lower than you’d like. Paul proclaims that we are more than conquerors in Christ. What more do we really need?
2. Glorifies Materialism
One of the grossest sins in America is the infatuation with money and reputation. I live in Dallas where everyone is in debt up to their eyeballs in order to be seen as one of the North Dallas elites. It doesn’t matter that you make $35,000 per year as long as people think you make $200,000. It’s a scary place to be to think that God wants your wealth because he is ultimately concerned with your renown and happiness. There is a reason that faithful believers in the Bible struggled at one point or another by earthly standards – God was teaching them to refocus their standards according to his. Wealth is not sinful in and of itself, but should never be sought as though you deserve it.
3. Elevates Moralism
It is pretty clear in any prosperity sermon that you are blessed if you are wealthy. A key phrase for a prosperity preacher is, “Are you broke? Does your car need new tires? Did you only get peanut butter and jelly sandwiches for lunch this week? It’s because you haven’t unlocked God’s ultimate plan for you!” He (or she) proceeds to tell you that if you do this and that, God will bless you. What is this blessing? MONEY. Duh. What more could you need to be happy? Forget reckless abandon for Christ and his Kingdom, as long as you got Chili’s instead of tuna salad this week. God’s blessing is him. You get HIM with no stipulations.





[...] Explanation of why I can’t accept the prosperity gospel [...]
Great reminders! May God protect us and keep us all from distorting the Gospel…
Chuckling at your Dallas comments… We called these guys $30,000 Millionaires.” It’s certainly everywhere, but good grief was it epidemic in Big D!
any good resources you can recommend to teach us how to lovingly approach and expose this error to friends and family deeply embedded in this prosperity gospel belief, including signs and wonders, prayer furnace, etc? Thanks for this article.
So you are saying God wants us to be poor?
I am trying to rack my brains to remember what Jesus said about this… Oh yes :) Mark 10:21
Jake,
I said… “Wealth is not sinful in and of itself, but should never be sought as though you deserve it.” There’s your answer. :)
Jesus wants us not to care about having the stuff of this world. He is our example. He turned down those things from Satan. Remember?
[...] distorts the gospel of Christ. Here are three major things that I think the prosperity gospel does: Read the rest.Share this:FacebookTwitterEmailMoreStumbleUponRedditDiggLinkedInPrintPinterestTumblr In [...]
I recently heard a preacher say that “Christ is a servant leader, He wants to serve you…” And then the preacher listed how – to help you get a car/house/college degree… I think the preachers take on Christ’s servant leadership does a very good job summing up the prosperity gospel.
To argue a point that either the “prosperity gospel” (or any point) is right or wrong misses the entire point of Christ and salvation. Facts: 1) Scripture tells me in Deut. 28 that by obeying the VOICE of the LORD GOD many of the blessings of God are “materialistic.” Also God’s chosen were to be given a promised LAND…that was a real, physical place. (2) In that Mark 10:21 passage Jesus did in fact tell that guy to go and sell all of what he had and follow Him. So there seems to be two sides of the coin so which side is God’s righteousness?? The KEY: Follow what Jesus says and against such there is no law. Good news is He GIVES us His Spirit to guide us in ALL truth, and again His sheep hear His voice. There is a common misconception that all I need is the Scriptures and I can discern all truth…sorry the flesh can’t think its way to salvation. Thus, “But you do not have His word abiding in you, because whom He sent, Him you do not believe. You search the Scriptures, for in them you think you have eternal life; and these are they which testify of Me. But you are not willing to come to Me that you may have life.” (John 5:38-40) Therefore, the heart of the matter is our heart, if our heart is on Jesus then He will give us everything we ask of Him…The rub: If I am asking Him what I need and He tells me, and I ask for that (no matter what it is) then why would He not give it to me? Christ’s servitude to me is that He tell me everything, guide me through everything and save me from sin and ultimately death, my only job is to believe Him for then I will do everything He asks of me…be His servant, friend and bride. Amen.
For the sake of not being disqualified in my statement, providing the good news is not arguing a point, it is the revelation of truth which the flesh suppresses. To some it is a saving grace, but to others death and destruction.
What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel http://t.co/JSCpv2k7
What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel | Project TGM http://t.co/nku6ZfPU
Amen fame and fortune are held out as something that fulfills and they don’t we in our fallen nature desperately want God to see things our way. One of my Charles Spurgeon devotionals he pointed out the fact that wealth can be deceiving when you can write a cheque and your temporal problems go away. I would rather hunger for Him and His righteousness. I guess I am trying to say they appeal to our base desires and call them “spiritual” Jesus said can we gather fruit from the thistles?
To me the fatal flaw of the prosperity gospel is that it inverts Jesus’ words in the Sermon on the Mount. It sees treasure on earth as more significant and desirable than treasure in heaven.
What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel | Project TGM http://t.co/YncXWJ26 via @ProjectTGM
[...] a brief explanation of each of these here. Share this:TwitterEmailFacebookDiggPrintLike this:LikeBe the first to like [...]
Jesus did not have your material wealth in mind when he died on the cross. No, Jesus had your eternal soul in mind. http://t.co/NqphNqMe
#NailedIt RT @TheThirstyTheo: What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel http://t.co/xtJz0NyJ
[...] What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel - If you read this site you’re probably convinced that the prosperity gospel is unbiblical. This short article takes a look at how the prosperity gospel distorts the true gospel. Share this:FacebookTwitterPinterestLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. ← the mythical “pastoral call”; it does not originate in the Bible~ [...]
Excited for my bro Brandon Smith. This article of his was featured on The Gospel Coalition website. Praise God for His grace. I thank God for Brandon’s friendship and for his love of Jesus and His gospel.
http://projecttgm.com/2012/10/what-the-prosperity-gospel-does-to-the-gospel/
[...] By Brandon Smith: [...]
What the prosperity gospel does to the gospel: http://t.co/gOLeubHL
[...] You do know that the Prosperity Gospel is not really the Gospel, don’t you? Consider what the Prosperity Gospel does to the Gospel. [...]
What is so wrong with the prosperity gospel? http://t.co/z6KeCu1v
[...] the criticism. I think when it comes to the Prosperity Gospel – that’s exactly what THIS POST [...]
What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel :: http://t.co/mh40Ryjc // “Wealth is not sinful in and of itself, but…”
[...] Now, as for the reason this lady gave me this money, I probably would disagree with her. More than likely, she believes that giving is an obligation for God’s blessing. And if you don’t give, God won’t bless you. (This prosperity gospel cheapens God’s grace.) [...]
[...] What the Prosperity Gospel Does to the Gospel by Brandon [...]
Amen! The so called prosperity gospel is really just a gospel of greed. It is “give to get” and uses God as a bank account, promising a “100 fold return”. Who wouldn’t invest their funds in a bank promising such an amount of interest on investment? God has been reduced to a bank .of investment of funds. not the Lord God . Hey, I could use extra cash but my God is more important & I’ll go by His will day to day even if it means I don’t get that mansion I want!!!!